Olive Oil Banana Bread



A couple of weeks ago Bon Appetit published a “Best Ultimate Classic Perfect Recipes” article online.  All of the recipes looked very interesting and I decided that I would spend the next couple of weeks trying the baking recipes to see if they really were perfect.  My first was Julia’s Best Banana Bread.

I have to say, I made it and it was the best.  Super moist, sweet, but not too sweet, and had a really nice banana flavor (I let my bananas get very, very ripe).  The only problem was that it fell in the middle.  Badly.  The recipe said to bake it for about 60-70 minutes, so I automatically set the timer to 60 and walked away.  When I came back, the loaf was a little over done, and so sunken in the middle that a hot dog could rest very comfortably.  I was disappointed, but I tried it anyway. It was delicious, just a little doughy as you cut your way to the middle.  The perfectionist in me needed to try it again, adjusting the baking time.


I bought more bananas and let them sit on the counter for about 5 days.  Ok, I may have gotten a little lazy and let them sit a little longer than 5 days.  One day, I came home from work and could smell the bananas from the kitchen.  They weren’t super dark brown, but the aroma was telling me that it’s now or never.  I started prepping my recipe and realized that I didn’t have any vegetable oil.  I used the last of it when I baked the first loaf and forgot to buy more at the market.  Ugh!  I stood there staring at my empty cupboard willing a bottle to appear, but it didn’t work.  Then I unsuccessfully tried to talk myself into running out to the market to buy more oil, but the idea of leaving the house again didn’t sound appealing, so I searched for options.  There’s always butter, but I wanted to be a little more daring since this was turning into a baking experiment.  I thought about sesame oil, but was afraid it would overpower the banana (and it sounded a little gross to me).  Peeking out behind the peanut oil and balsamic vinegar was good old extra virgin olive oil.  This seemed like my somewhat safest choice.  I threw the batter together and put it in the oven.  This time I would check the loaf after 45 minutes.

When I checked the bread, there was a nice dome happening, but it was still very shaky even thought the bread was already very brown.  I decided to bake it for another 10-15 minutes.   Well, it was done, but it fell again the in the middle.  Not nearly as bad as the first time, but still it fell and I wasn’t happy.  I let it cool and took a bite.  The bite quickly turned into me shoving over half of the slice in my mouth.  Holy crap this was good!  There was such a depth of flavor.  It was still sweet, but now, subtle and earthy.  I’ll never go back to vegetable oil again.  As for the dip in the middle?  I think I can live with it.  It also could be because my baking soda is a bit old.  I should check the expiration date.

Olive Oil Banana Bread

  • 1¾ cups all-purpose flour
  • 1½ teaspoon baking soda
  • ¾ teaspoon kosher salt
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1½ cups sugar
  • 1 cup mashed ripe bananas ((about 2 large))
  • ¾ cup extra virgin olive oil
  1. Preheat oven to 350°. Coat a 9x5x3” loaf pan with nonstick spray. Whisk flour, baking soda, and salt in a medium bowl. Whisk eggs, sugar, bananas, and oil in a large bowl until smooth. Add dry ingredients to banana mixture and stir just until combined. Scrape batter into prepared pan and smooth top.
  2. Bake until a tester inserted into the center of bread comes out clean, 50-60 minutes. Transfer to a wire rack; let bread cool in pan for 15 minutes. Run a knife around inside of pan to release the bread. Turn out onto rack and let cool completely.

Adapted from Bon Appetit

15 Comments Add yours

  1. How interesting! From what I know about evoo and oo (which is limited) is that the difference has more to do with the refinement of the oils and not so much with weight. It’s like the equivalent between using refined sugar vs white. I’m very intrigued though, I may have to try it myself 🙂

  2. Jn says:

    I used 1/2 cup olive oil and 2 cups flour, 1 tspn each baking powder and soda. I made 2 loaves exactly the same except the oil. The olive oil loaf collapsed a little. The other o e did not. Maybe the evoo is heavier???

  3. Kristen R. says:

    Looks fantastic! I love the ingenuity of trying out new ingredients in classic recipes like this – super helpful when you find yourself in the middle of a baking project and out of an essential ingredient. Thanks so much for sharing!

  4. Great! I’m glad it worked out. I’ll have to try that myself

  5. C says:

    I used bread whole wheat flour…no dip…..delicious!!!

  6. Wow! So glad that mystery is solved. After living in apartments for so many years, I’ve started using oven thermometers. Can’t live without them! I’ve had to recalibrate various ovens at least once. I’m so glad you like the recipe 🙂

  7. Juliet Funt says:

    Hey there – I think I solved it and it was about our oven’s thermostat which needed to be replaced. This is by far the best banana bread ever!

  8. I used a 9 x 5 inch metal loaf pan and extra virgin olive oil. I’m very curious to see the color of your bread. Would you mind posting a pic? Or you could email me @ cheryl@neuroticbaker.com.

  9. Juliet Funt says:

    It’s already at the top. What kind of pan did you use? And did you use an extra light oil? I split it into two little loaves and the color was perfect with the shorter baking time but the big one is a nicer presentation. I also tried a slower longer bake but the color was the same.

  10. The oil will definitely make the crust darker in general. What position is your rack in the oven? Because my oven runs hot, I tend to bake things on the top or second to top level. Anything lower and everything looks like burnt toast!

  11. Juliet Funt says:

    I love the taste but every time the outside of the loaf is very dark. Much darker than yours. I tried a shiny pan and lowering the temp and baking it at 325 and it’s dark outside every time. Any suggestions?

  12. Yes I think the ripeness can make a big difference, so I always say when in doubt, use less sugar. Happy Thanksgiving and Happy early Birthday!!

  13. webwriter4u says:

    That is a good point about the sugar and the ripeness of the bananas! I’m making this for my birthday party on Saturday. Happy Thanksgiving! Also, I used whole wheat flour, not all purpose. It was great. I didn’t notice that when I wrote up my modification.

  14. I’m glad you liked it! I think you can play around with the sugar depending on how ripe your bananas are. I love your addition of applesauce. Now I’ll have to try your version! 🙂

  15. webwriter4u says:

    I modified this recipe slightly, and it is the BEST banana bread I’ve ever made. I cut the sugar in half – used less olive oil and added apple sauce. I normally use walnuts and chocolate chips – which are not needed. It is really fantastic. I also used at least 3 extremely ripe bananas, if not four. Might have been more than 1 cup, I didn’t measure. Here’s my modified recipe – seriously, the best banana bread!!!

    1¾ cups all-purpose flour

    1½ teaspoon baking soda

    ¾ teaspoon kosher salt

    3 large eggs

    3/4 cup sugar

    3 or four ripe bananas

    1/2 cup extra virgin olive oil

    1/2 cup applesauce

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s